(Everyone should take this more seriously than I and add!)
  1. CBGB
  2. Times Square ESPN Zone
  3. Derek Jeter
  4. Old Penn Station (insult to injury: the gaping maw of hell they replaced it with)
    Suggested by @zoe
  5. Nearly all of the Gray's Papayas
    Suggested by @gabe
  6. The Pink Pony, Max Fish, The Living Room and the rest of Ludlow Street
    Suggested by @michelle
  7. Times Square
    Suggested by @teo
  8. Fashion Week in Bryant Park
    Suggested by @teo
  9. Fulton Fish Market and Cafe Figaro, both mafia conference rooms
    Suggested by @thebfg