Just soft suggestions; if you already have your own ideas, go with it
  1. A copy of a book you love (doesn't need to be new) with notes from you written all through it
    like: "this is my favorite part," or "I always cry here," or "this reminds me of..." or "haha, this kills me!"
  2. An ornament that represents you a little bit
    It might be something you're into, or where you're from
  3. I love homemade cookies
    because homemade cookies are made with butter! If baking is your thing and you happen to be making some, put some aside for me please! Might be a pain to ship, though. Please don't poison me
  4. I'm gonna appreciate the heck out of whatever you decide to send 💖
    unless you poison me