It's Time for Everyone's Favorite Gameshow ... IS IT A RECIPE OR A SHOPPING LIST?!?!

We'll start of slow. First clue:
  1. Nutella
  2. Bread
  3. Mushrooms
  4. Is it a recipe or a shopping list? First to buzz. Ready?
  5. Sometimes lists of seemingly incongruous things crack me up. I don't know. I'm weird.