Flavor, brand, etc. ⚪️ A "crowd list" is a list where we all chime in on a common topic/question/survey/poll.
  1. Suggest your answers below! ⬇️
  2. Two ice creams
    Flavor doesn't matter as long as I'm double fisting 🍦🍦
    Suggested by @HisDudeness
  3. Blue Moon. Light blue, tastes like Fruit Loops, sometimes has mini marshmallows in it. Why yes, I am a grown man.
    Suggested by @roche
  4. Chocolate brownie
    Suggested by @estherlimtf
  5. Mint chocolate chip
    Does anyone have any vegan recommendations?
    Suggested by @notfunny
  6. Chocolate fudge brownie... Although I'll eat any flavor of ice cream to be honest
    Suggested by @MatthewAlmont
  7. Spumoni! It's not just for Christmas!
    Honorable mention:pineapple sherbet.
    Suggested by @jennifergster
  8. Gonna be that person and say the ice cream my city just got called One Buffalo
    It has sponge candy in it and I've been going around the ice cream to eat them.
    Suggested by @libby92
  9. Ben and Jerry's Spectaculoos cookie core or Haagen das strawberry 🍓🍓🍓🍪🍪🍪
    Suggested by @yikes
  10. Black Raspberry
    Suggested by @uhohlivia
  11. Gingerbread ice cream
    I'll take pretty much any kind though
    Suggested by @eetak
  12. Mmmm - Coffee
    But I make my own ice cream and I'm currently jamming on vanilla with Bing cherries and bittersweet chocolate chunks.
    Suggested by @lynn0826
  13. I'm going to second cookie dough.
    Suggested by @macnchz
  14. Tropical Dreams coconut chocolate
    The BEST ice cream I have ever had in my life and you can only get it in Hawaii.
    Suggested by @rachhello
  15. This is by far the best ice cream ever, and it makes me sad I can't find it anymore
    Suggested by @WhitneyRayeF
  16. Cool Brittania. Retired Ben and Jerry's flavor.
    Chocolate covered shortbread in a strawberry ice cream. I'm in mourning still.
    Suggested by @jannychan
  17. Strawberry.
    But ever since Bryers got gross there are no good grocery store strawberry ice creams anymore so I only have it at the ice cream parlor.
    Suggested by @gwcoffey
  18. Häagen-Dazs Mint Chip
    Follows closely by their Coffee flavor.
    Suggested by @LizDawson
  19. Mint chocolate chip.
    Honestly so hard to find the good stuff in the UK 😞
    Suggested by @DawnCloud
  20. Ben and Jerry's Cinnamon Buns
    it has a streusel swirl. And chunks of cinnamon roll. I dream of this ice cream.
    Suggested by @brightlyanna
  21. Rocky Road
    If anybody knows of a brand that uses walnuts instead of almonds let me know.
    Suggested by @jaidub
  22. I'm 100% with @Fitz on this one 🙌🏼
    Suggested by @allysonarno
  23. Double Dunker from Turkey Hill!
    Suggested by @hannah_rachel
  24. Chocolate-Raspberry
    Homemade from a local place down the shore. Chocolate ice cream, raspberry swirls, plus tiny chocolate cups filled with raspberry sauce (mixed in, not on top).
    Suggested by @DG
  25. Peppermint Stick! 💕
    Suggested by @lizabeth
  26. Chubby Hubby
    Suggested by @ErinFlaherty
  27. Pistachio Honey from Jeni's or Strawberry Chocolate Chunk from Graeter's.
    Sorry, I live in Columbus and we're kind of spoiled snobs when it comes to ice cream.
    Suggested by @NeighborFoodie
  28. Milk and Cookies! The best of Chocolate Chip Cookies Dough and Cookies and Cream all in one!
    Suggested by @kirbstr
  29. Blue Bell's The Great Divide plus caramel sauce in the middle.
    ...this is the economic way of attacking Ben & Jerry's Karamel Sutra
    Suggested by @themohawkmoon
  30. Blue Bell Cookies and Cream
    Suggested by @thecomicswife
  31. Turkey Hill - Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
    Suggested by @akazan
  32. Talenti Gelato Mediterranean Mint
    Suggested by @empassini