A thorough investigation
  1. Charles Evans Whittaker
    F7dcde71 40d4 436a a2fc 1c27bc62019b
    Ugh, what an unhuggable jerk. If the picture's not enough, know that he was viewed as spineless and wishy-washy and later spoke out against the Civil Rights Movement. No hugs for you.
  2. John Marshall Harlan II
    A266e5cc be79 48e7 8d31 9c08ef1308a2
    Totally would go for the handshake first and then try to turn it into bro hug while making things way more awkward. Points for supporting desegregation, but basically just voted the same way his mentor, Felix Frankfurter, and was even dubbed "Frankfurter without mustard."
  3. Potter Stewart
    929e41af 8b6f 4693 a537 587019413e8b
    A bit standoffish, but once you got in there he'd give a solid - if rigid - squeeze. One of the key movers in Roe v. Wade, so you know he knows how to treat a lady (with the respectful understanding that she can make decisions about her own body).
  4. Earl Warren
    F35ad410 b9c7 4ee6 9058 15ca9461e933
    A chief hug for Eisenhower's sole Chief Justice appointee. He'd come at you with a nice big bear hug. Might even throw in a tickle! Probably could use a hug too after having to oversee the "Warren Commission" investigation into the JFK assassination 😔
  5. William J Brennan Jr.
    3fe6ab7f 7406 4935 88a1 6c9e3deccc44
    What a cutie!