SECRETLY HOT GUYS YOU WENT TO HIGH SCHOOL WITH

  1. The one with the hoodie
    He was secretly pretty hot
  2. The one in the grade below you
    Remember him? Pretty hot, secretly
  3. The one who quit the lacrosse team
    Hot, but only in secret
  4. The one named Jake
    You wouldn't think it outside of secretly, but damn - he was pretty hot
  5. The one who ate tater tots
    One of the best kept secrets about him? Hot
  6. The one with the locker
    HOT. But shhhh...this one's a secret ;)
  7. The one who is your brother
    No secret here! Love you Brett