They were so great
  1. Two-headed Michael.
    B95396e1 7915 4b72 971e 2dbbbd8159a5
    The fact that there were two Michaels in this episode was great. Also it made an appearance in another episode, so that's always awesome.
  2. The Joker (Creed)
    13055fbe ad29 4790 8e01 59205954d8b8
    Creed is weird enough as himself, but when he has all the makeup and even acts like The Joker, it adds a whole new level of weird.
  3. A kitten (Andy)
    1e792928 d443 4eae a134 f54ac4b39c43
    Andy obviously spent too much time on this costume, and when he got bent-out-of-shape when Jim called him a cat and not a kitten, it was absolutely priceless!
  4. Charlie Chaplin (Pam) @JennaFischer
    Db3f5678 7f87 413c 9c9f e958c22eb642
    When I saw Pam in this episode for the first time, I legitimately belly-laughed. When Pam took off her hat and looked like an extremely feminine Hitler, I was so dead😂
  5. MacGruber! (Michael)
    B9e5898f 084f 4a46 8aa6 b2bc55ccb142
    Michael was extremely excited about this costume, and every time he looked at the camera and yelled, "MacGruber!" , I died laughing
  6. BookFace (Jim)
    Another one of Jim's creative "costumes", I chose this one above the rest for the fact that Darryl thought he was BookFave and not FaceBook!
  7. Michael Moore (Kevin)
    8e9e20f7 0447 4842 832a 079d07f977ab
    It's scary how much Kevin looks like Michael Moore in this.
  8. Popeye (Jim)
    C95304bf 7775 43fa b23c 010d609e0993
    Jim dressed up!?!?!?! And it was to make Pam happy, which is extremely romantic.
  9. Queen of Blades (Dwight)
    C70ea25a 31b5 4840 ad69 c2f921827bd4
    WTF was this?!
  10. Creed
    61cfeebb 371e 49b5 93b1 bc949fa0924a
    Such good timing...
  11. Carrie Bradshaw and Gordie Gecko (Kelly and Ryan) @bjnovak @mindy
    E740b1db a0ba 4568 8247 804c1d5346a0
    They were so cute!