Best to worst.
  1. Janeway
    Haters gonna hate. I don't kur. She beats the Borg Queen with one federation ship, light years from home.
  2. Sisko
    He proves his dominance over Picard in episode one of Deep Space Nine. Rewatch it if you don't believe me.
  3. Picard
    I know most of you think he's the best. I think he's a great captain, just not greatest captain.
  4. TOS Kirk
    Makes questionable decisions, but don't they all? Still love him and his... Cadence of speech.
  5. Archer
    Honestly, kind of forgettable. He has a cute dog and he was the quantum leap guy, so there's that.
  6. Movie Kirk
    Um. Somehow you managed to make Kirk more reckless and masochistic. JJ didn't really get these characters. That much is clear.