Inspired by @MatthewAlmont (also I interpreted "favorite" as movies that are meaningful/important to me; a "best" list would look different)
  1. 1992: Aladdin
    Static
  2. 1993: Mrs. Doubtfire
    Static
  3. 1994: Reality Bites
    Static
  4. 1995: Before Sunrise
    Static
  5. 1996: Space Jam
    Static
  6. 1997: Good Will Hunting
    Static
  7. 1998: The Parent Trap
    Static
  8. 1999: 10 Things I Hate About You
    Static
  9. 2000: Memento
    Static
  10. 2001: Ocean's Eleven
    Static
    Honorable Mentions: Monsters Inc., Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, The Princess Diaries
  11. 2002: Big Fat Liar
    Static
  12. 2003: Big Fish
    Static
  13. 2004: Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
    Static
    Honorable Mention: Before Sunset
  14. 2005: Pride & Prejudice
    Static
    Honorable Mention: Walk the Line
  15. 2006: The Departed
    Static
  16. 2007: There Will Be Blood
    Static
  17. 2008: Forgetting Sarah Marshall
    Static
    Honorable Mention: Revolutionary Road
  18. 2009: Zombieland
    Static
  19. 2010: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (Part 1)
    Static
  20. 2011: Bridesmaids
    Static
  21. 2012: Celeste and Jesse Forever
    Static
  22. 2013: The Way, Way Back
    Static
  23. 2014: Her
    Static
  24. 2015: Inside Out
    Static
  25. 2016: still to come!