Top three to five seems reasonable.
  1. Amelie, Kingsman, Brothers Bloom, Pride & Prejudice, Harry Potter 7.1
  2. Paper Man, Never Let Me Go, Shutter Island, Inside Out, The Place Beyond the Pines
    As of right now, at least.
    Suggested by @kaitmaree
  3. Rushmore, Fargo, Boogie Nights, The Lion King, The Silence of the Lambs, You've Got Mail, Her
    Suggested by @sarahgorman
  4. Bruno, Sound of Music, and a rotating third
    Suggested by @biz
  5. The Lord of the Rings, The Impossible, Scott Pilgrim vs the World, Inception, Lilo and Stitch
    Suggested by @joemurphy
  6. The Hours, The Silence of the Lambs, Mamma Mia, Love Actually, The Bridges of Madison County
    Suggested by @nervesofscared
  7. Dr Strangelove, In the Mood for Love, ghost world
    Suggested by @ceelbomb
  8. Liberal Arts, Shaun of the Dead, Zombieland, Inception, Bridesmaids.
    Suggested by @franksars
  9. Birdman, Penelope, When Harry Met Sally, School of Rock, Wet Hot American Summer
    Suggested by @leahgayle
  10. Waiting for Guffman, Wall-E, The Shining.
    My tried and true trio.
    Suggested by @lizabeth
  11. Forrest Gump, Me and Earl and the Dying Girl, Moonrise Kingdom, Mean Girls, February, Harry Potter (all were good), Cowboy, Son of Saul, It's kind of a funny story, and I'm sure a bunch more that I forget right now
    Suggested by @ellasabo
  12. Fight Club, Mean Girls, Hell In The Pacific, Cast Away, it's. A Wonderful Life
    Suggested by @pili_ervin
  13. Silence of the Lambs, The Thin Red Line, Seven, High Fidelity, Pulp Fiction
    Suggested by @awej81
  14. You've Got Mail, Sense & Sensibility, the Sound of Music
    If we're defining "favorites" as movies we could watch every single day.
    Suggested by @jessnobs
  15. The Philadelphia Story, Amelie, Wings of Desire, Monsoon Wedding, Some Kind of Wonderful, Rushmore, Aladdin.
    Suggested by @wonderishmama
  16. Moonstruck, This is Spïnal Tap, Life of Brian, Top Gun, Pride and Prejudice (Colin Firth version)
    Suggested by @cylontrekker
  17. The Sound of Music, A League of Their Own, and Philadelphia
    Gah it's so hard to pick!!
    Suggested by @jaliasc
  18. Being There, Forrest Gump, Fast Times
    Suggested by @jon
  19. Sound of Music, Forrest Gump, & Magic of Ordinary Days
    Suggested by @mamie
  20. Snatch, Talladega Nights, The Dark Knight, The Grinch (live-action Jim Carrey version), Superbad
    Suggested by @SuperCarter
  21. Back to the Future, Teen Witch
    I ❤️ 80s movies
    Suggested by @kaymaldo
  22. 10 Things I Hate About You, The Little Rascals, Master of Disguise, Pride and Prejudice, Dead Poet's Society
    Suggested by @michellehoehne
  23. Lord of the Rings, The Lion King, Star Trek XI, Bride & Prejudice, Inception, The Bourne Identity, both Captain America films
    Suggested by @crackdkettle
  24. Elf, Clueless, Tangled, and Monsters University
    Suggested by @chloeabzzz
  25. The Goonies, Jurassic Park, It Happened One Night, Harry Potter series, About Time
    Suggested by @KikiHines
  26. The Wizard of Oz, Gremlins 2: The New Batch, Amelie, House of 1,000 Corpses, Blazing Saddles
    Suggested by @peachney
  27. Slumdog Millionaire, The Lord of the Rings, Sense and Sensibility, Little Women, Salmon Fishing in the Yemen
    Suggested by @rcwornhoff
  28. The Rules of Attraction, Igby Goes Down, Hot Rod, Love & Basketball, and Prime
    Suggested by @caseycruda
  29. Tootsie, The Lives of Others, Fargo, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, The Social Network
    Suggested by @maggielocker
  30. Almost Famous, Dogfight, Se7en, Notting Hill
    Suggested by @bailey
  31. Pans Labyrinth, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Silence of the Lambs, Royal Tennenbaums
    Suggested by @rebeccaroanoke
  32. Precious, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, Jackie Brown
    Suggested by @danielmuto
  33. Flirting with Disaster, Defending Your Life, Up
    Suggested by @theranman
  34. Sound of Music, Bridget Jones' Diary, Waitress, Aladdin, Notting Hill
    Suggested by @justjills