Hit me.
  1. Sugar Factory
    New. Big. Always booked. I need more ideas.
  2. Sundaes & Cones
    Not a lot of seating though
    Suggested by @carey
  3. Morgenstern's Finest Ice-Cream
    Suggested by @madeline
  4. The Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory, DUMBO
    It's super cute and simply old school in the fireboat/light house. Homemade! Small but solid selection. Not much seating inside, but lots of benches on the pier outside, basically walking on water. And throughout the surrounding park. Beautiful stunning view of NYC and right under BK bridge. I always go at night during the winter and it's still worth it! Great area for social wandering too
    Suggested by @willadoor
  5. Van Leeuwen
    Super cute. The East Village location has a bit of seating but not fountain soda shop style.
    Suggested by @michelle