1. Officer Krupke (West Side Story)
    my favorite song in the musical
  2. Earl Devereaux (Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs)
    "my chest hairs are tingling!"
  3. Doughnut Sheriff (Amazing World of Gumball)
  4. Detective Gumshoe (Phoenix Wright franchise)
    what a pal
  5. Carl Winslow (Family Matters)
  6. Inspector Gadget (Inspector Gadget)
    best theme song
  7. Chief Wiggum
    Suggested by   @bibblite
  8. Jake Peralta
    Suggested by   @Kawnr
  9. Barney Fife
    Suggested by   @andersun
  10. Carlton Lassiter-Psych
    Suggested by   @corksnreads
  11. Axel Foley
    Okay, the other two, Detectives Rosewood & Taggert, were pretty awesome as well.
    Suggested by   @solitarygigi
  12. Leo D'Amato, Veronica Mars
    Suggested by   @cordeliane