AKA ON THE OFFICE

Or The Mistaken Identities
  1. Shrueberry blue
    💯💯💯 Dwight
  2. William Charles Schnider
    Creed
  3. Monkey
    Angela
  4. Beesly
    Pam
  5. Nard Dog
    Andy
  6. Lord Rupert Everton
    Michael
  7. Jimothy
    Jim
  8. Possum
    Dwight
  9. Reeg - Rogers - Mr Rogers
    Darryl
  10. The Temp
    Ryan
  11. Fire Guy
    Ryan
  12. Sea Monster
  13. Jim Samtanko
    Jim's Second Life avatar
  14. Michael Scorn
  15. Michael Scarn
  16. Michael Scotch
  17. Michael the Magic
  18. Ping
    Michael
  19. Prison Mike
    Michael
  20. Michael Klump
    Michael
  21. Mykonos
    Michael
  22. Date Mike
    Michael
  23. Necropolis
    Holly
  24. Boner Champ
    Andy
  25. (Big) Tuna
    Jim
  26. Pamcakes
    Pam
  27. Dwigt
    Dwight
  28. Fear
    Moes
  29. Packman
    Packer
  30. Pama-lama-ding-dong
    Pam
  31. Dwayne
    Dwight
  32. Narc
    Dwight
  33. D
    Dwight
  34. Ignorant slut
    Dwight
  35. Pudge
    Madge
  36. Baby Wawa
    Andy
  37. Dwight Jr
    Clark
  38. Plop
    Pete
  39. Babe
    Jan & Michael
  40. Peepa
    Cece
  41. Cece
    Cecilia Halpert
  42. Chumbo
    Kevin
    Suggested by   @danariley