1. The original Cats
  2. Phantom of the Opera
    With Michael Crawford
  3. Into the Woods
    The Joanna Gleason production
  4. Company
    With Beth Howland
  5. Spring Awakening
    Jonathan Groff and Lea Michele
    It's tough to choose between when it was off Broadway (and I could afford it) and the Jonathan Groff production. But I'll take anything.