In precise descending order of excellence
  1. Paul Newman, Hud
  2. Leo, The Great Gatsby
  3. Bradley Cooper, Limitless
  4. James Marsden, Hop
  5. Leo, The Departed
  6. Bradley Cooper, Limitless
  7. Wes Bentley, American Beauty
  8. Bradley Cooper, Aloha
    Yes we know the film was garbage save it
  9. Leo, Titanic
  10. Jake Gyllenhaal, Brokeback Mountain
  11. Josh Lucas, Sweet Home Alabama