Inspired by @LizDawson; there are other songs, but these are strictly from The Baptist Hymnal, which I fondly recall flipping through on Sundays (rather than listening to the sermon, usually) since I was a child.
  1. Holy Holy Holy
    Mostly only the Sufjan version though, but it's the first listed in the hymnal, so I had to include it.
  2. Come Thou Fount of Every Blessing
    Sufjan covers this too and it's beautiful, but I love it as a traditional hymn as well.
  3. How Great Thou Art
  4. Amazing Grace
    Another one that Sufjan covers. Maybe I should just title this "Best hymns that Sufjan does". Again, referring to the hymn primarily.
  5. Just As I Am
  6. I Have Decided to Follow Jesus
    I don't get this one, bc it's quite repetitive.
  7. Turn Your Eyes Upon Jesus
  8. Be Thou My Vision
  9. Day By Day
  10. Pass It On
    This one.
  11. The Old Rugged Cross
  12. Because He Lives
  13. America the Beautiful
    Never heard it in church, but it's at the end of this hymnal, and always gets me.