What a pickle we've gotten ourselves into!
  1. "The Girl is Mine" - Michael Jackson & Paul McCartney
  2. "The Boy is Mine" - Brandy & Monica
  3. "Same Girl" - R. Kelly & Usher
  4. "jolene" -- dolly parton
    Suggested by @lindsaygelfand
  5. Does He Love You? by Reba McEntire and Linda Davis
    Suggested by @SGGinNYC
  6. El Paso. "The handsome young stranger lay dead on the floor."
    Suggested by @fats
  7. Does He Love You? - Rilo Kiley
    And your husband will never leave you, he will never leave you for me! UGH IT KILLS ME EVERY TIME
  8. She's Not Me - Jenny Lewis
    Suggested by @betsy