Requested by @k8mcgarry
A few suggestions
  1. Switch cleansers
    It's not the moisturizer. The cleanser is overstripping your skin. Your skin is then producing a ton of oil to compensate for the dryness, causing the oiliness at the end of the day. Switch to a super gentle or oil cleanser, continue with the moisturizer. It takes a few weeks for skin to reset itself and stop overproducing the oil.
  2. Rejoice
    A few years of oil is NOTHING compared to the agony of dry, aging skin that is dry girls have. I would kill for "oily" skin. All my friends who had this problem look at least 6 years younger than me.