The best places for key lime pie in Key West
  1. Caroline's
    Perfect balance between sweet and tart. Not too dense
  2. Blond Giraffe
    Close second. Actually in Key Largo
  3. 6-Toed Cat
    Dense and delicious
  4. Kermit's Frozen
    Perfect for a hot day
  5. Hogfish Bar and Grill
    Where the locals go
  6. Alonso's Key Lime martini
    Plan to stay awhile
  7. Kelly's Key Lime margarita
  8. Blue Heaven
    Not a meringue fan but highly recommended by the locals