limited myself to one per show because there are literally dozens of Idol/ANTM contestants who qualify
  1. Michelle, America's Next Top Model (cycle 4)
    D5392506 8d12 4af7 976e 779b0f70b29a
    Developed impetigo while on the show. Didn't really fit in with the other girls, or seem to enjoy being on a reality show. Briefly married Jonny Fairplay, one of my least favorite Survivor contestants.
  2. Mitchell, Project Runway (season 6)
    95641168 1210 4c44 8974 f11baaffaa45
    Deservedly Bottom 2'd his first two weeks on the season. Couldn't really sew, and really shouldn't have been cast, but sweet as can be. Mercy killed after the third challenge despite his team's winning look.
  3. Syesha Mercado, American Idol (season 7)
    3f0110f7 dc38 4b8a 9bc8 10a7c74a6eaf
    Chronic over-smiler, but super talented and desperate to survive, barely scraping by every week. The judges didn't give her the credit she deserved for her voice, and once she (somehow) made her way to the final 3, the producers sabotaged her by making her sing "Hit Me Up" from the Happy Feet soundtrack.
  4. Katie Waissel, The X Factor UK (season 7)
    94481487 23ac 450b be0c c08e4b9b43ec
    By no means the most talented act her season (the One Direction season), but probably the most thirsty to entertain. Still, a bottom 2 fixture until the top 7. Once ended a nervous, shaky elimination night cover of a song called "Don't Give Up On Me" on the floor, pleading for the judges to keep her. Plus she got heaps of bad press while she was on the show for lasting longer than more popular contestants.
  5. Cara Maria, MTV's The Challenge
    11892f39 ba27 4919 920c 0ac24eb37000
    Has appeared on 7 seasons and until recently was probably the most consistently ostracized by the other contestants. I never could figure out why they hated her, or why she kept coming back when they'd always make her cry in the end.
  6. Thing 1, Flavor of Love (season 3)
    5b52056d efcf 4f44 aa1a 80c16e531556
    Flav clearly preferred Thing 2