Disclaimer: I only really watched Seasons 6-11, but I was a RABID fan for those six seasons (like, "bought performances on iTunes" rabid). I limited it to one per contestant with one exception for Bae-ley Reinhart. Full playlist here: http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL2cBKJh2No9dz5nAGW3kCLxRTC-8fSsq-
  1. "Treat Her Like A Lady" - Lee DeWyze
    Ecb28a7c 2cfa 4740 9297 33df0d0c33e3
    Top 10, Season 9 (2010) - https://youtu.be/auiSLyKUpRE
  2. "Fixing A Hole" - Lilly Scott
    99d22bca cc43 4e04 b521 7df31338ad2c
    Top 24, Season 9 (2010) - https://youtu.be/wAeheOmuN1w
  3. "You Give Love A Bad Name" - Blake Lewis
    34d3c039 8cab 4354 b530 6268e684a0cf
    Top 6, Season 6 (2007) - https://youtu.be/C4IGm9E4W9g
  4. "Magic Man" - Kady Malloy
    Eeac5f69 dd1b 48a4 9a10 f5eda47b77f6
  5. "The Letter" - Michael Johns/Carly Smithson
    909c04df 776e 488c 8709 5f750ec23a90
  6. "I Put A Spell On You" - Casey Abrams
    Fb438c79 9b4f 4d9a 90f7 810ae5e75fc6
  7. "Hallelujah" - Jason Castro
    96617e6b 5f60 46fb b0c7 fbb723c35756
  8. "The Scientist" - Katelyn Epperly
    Ce04da1a 6801 49d9 9928 e0075e5ba55a
  9. "Jammin' (Master Blaster)" - DeAndre Brackensick
    0af86a36 476c 45e7 af9e 525b6669df95
  10. "I Who Have Nothing" - Jordin Sparks
    60aba3aa 8fca 4be7 8d50 cf1a2c441c10
  11. "Whole Lotta Love" - Adam Lambert
    6dc1d6f9 a349 4cea 9ffc ab457fe479bf
  12. "Since You've Been Gone" - Melinda Doolittle
    8a79dbda 2951 4de4 8a6b 6be1d0575e39
  13. "Vienna" - Elise Testone
    Dd1cc8fc 62bd 4c61 9549 cce43ef954c4
  14. "Heartless" - Kris Allen
    08faf44e 70f3 4566 84d0 9812e1fbf9ab
  15. "Let It Be" - Brooke White
    206ab6fb 8820 4a02 9bac e094e44f3190
  16. "Everybody Knows" - Alex Lambert
    52edc2cb b3db 4046 93c8 6ae92435c30a
  17. "Volcano" - Phillip Phillips
    89ca0800 e029 4d0c a4da b6efa45de38d
  18. "Hello" - David Cook
    D029e696 36a4 44a6 a5a6 5d6fe7a60e4c
  19. "Steal Away" - Jessica Sanchez
    025f76e5 ff85 470f 9c43 b1ff48ffe8dd
  20. "It's All Wrong But It's All Right" - Michael Johns
    543f6483 ada3 4bdc a2e6 033957996926
  21. "Who's Lovin' You" - Matt Giraud
    B1171a1e 92de 4243 9121 76cd4658fe77
  22. "Jealous Guy" - Casey James
    E66dc95f edf5 46ef 9735 6025e17c63c9
  23. "To Love Somebody" - Joshua Ledet
    C0de535a 317a 478b 8063 1f74668c34f6
  24. TIE: "House of the Rising Sun"/"What Is And What Should Never Be" - Haley Reinhart
    76cef334 06d4 4f09 a6ed 75c76c64ecd1
  25. "Moanin" - Haley Reinhart & Casey Abrams
    49453b0c 2170 483c be2a 520a8dff44aa
    Top 8 Results, Season 10 (2011) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVMYCDLAF4E