TOP 25 AMERICAN IDOL PERFORMANCES

Disclaimer: I only really watched Seasons 6-11, but I was a RABID fan for those six seasons (like, "bought performances on iTunes" rabid). I limited it to one per contestant with one exception for Bae-ley Reinhart. Full playlist here: http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL2cBKJh2No9dz5nAGW3kCLxRTC-8fSsq-
  1. 25.
    "Treat Her Like A Lady" - Lee DeWyze
    Top 10, Season 9 (2010) - https://youtu.be/auiSLyKUpRE
  2. 24.
    "Fixing A Hole" - Lilly Scott
    Top 24, Season 9 (2010) - https://youtu.be/wAeheOmuN1w
  3. 23.
    "You Give Love A Bad Name" - Blake Lewis
    Top 6, Season 6 (2007) - https://youtu.be/C4IGm9E4W9g
  4. 22.
    "Magic Man" - Kady Malloy
  5. 21.
    "The Letter" - Michael Johns/Carly Smithson
  6. 20.
    "I Put A Spell On You" - Casey Abrams
  7. 19.
    "Hallelujah" - Jason Castro
  8. 18.
    "The Scientist" - Katelyn Epperly
  9. 17.
    "Jammin' (Master Blaster)" - DeAndre Brackensick
  10. 16.
    "I Who Have Nothing" - Jordin Sparks
  11. 15.
    "Whole Lotta Love" - Adam Lambert
  12. 14.
    "Since You've Been Gone" - Melinda Doolittle
  13. 13.
    "Vienna" - Elise Testone
  14. 12.
    "Heartless" - Kris Allen
  15. 11.
    "Let It Be" - Brooke White
  16. 10.
    "Everybody Knows" - Alex Lambert
  17. 9.
    "Volcano" - Phillip Phillips
  18. 8.
    "Hello" - David Cook
  19. 7.
    "Steal Away" - Jessica Sanchez
  20. 6.
    "It's All Wrong But It's All Right" - Michael Johns
  21. 5.
    "Who's Lovin' You" - Matt Giraud
  22. 4.
    "Jealous Guy" - Casey James
  23. 3.
    "To Love Somebody" - Joshua Ledet
  24. 2.
    TIE: "House of the Rising Sun"/"What Is And What Should Never Be" - Haley Reinhart
  25. 1.
    "Moanin" - Haley Reinhart & Casey Abrams
    Top 8 Results, Season 10 (2011) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVMYCDLAF4E