This show has the best guest stars ever. But then just when you fall in love they're gone. Sometimes you know why they leave, other times they just disappear (only to show up out of the blue). Why you messing with my emotions like that?
  1. Finn Polmar (Matthew Goode)
    He gets #1 cause he never got with with Alicia.
  2. Will Gardner (Josh Charles)
    💔 I had a hard time even typing his name
  3. Ellsbert Tascioni (Carrie Preston)
    Look at this jacket! How do you not want to see her every damn day
  4. Lemond Bishop (Mike Colter)
    Jessica Jones blah blah. I want him to threaten people while wearing hot 3 piece suits
  5. Geneva Pine (Renee Elise Goldsberry)
    I wouldn't normally have ranked Geneva this high (even though she rocks tweed and jackets on the show), but now that she is in Hamilton I want her to come back and sing about Angelica.
  6. Kalinda Sharma (Archie Panjabj)
    I deserve a better ending. We all do
  7. Patti Nyholm (Martha Plimpton)
    I know she had most of the back and forth with Will. But I want her to show up with all kids in tow
  8. Wendy Scott-Carr (Anika Noni Rose)
    She would kill you with a smile. Will out maneuvers her and we never see her again.
  9. Andrew Wiley (Tim Guinee)
    True story. My friend bought me the lion speaker after seeing how much I enjoyed Andrew Wiley's.
  10. Julius Cain (Michael Boatman)
    I just kind of want him and Michel J Fox to have meta looks at each other all the time and be like "Spin city, am I right?"
  11. Natalie Flores (America Ferrera)
    I love how Eli only has love connections with Ugly Betty characters. Calling Becki Newton
  12. Robyn Burdine (Jess Weixler)
    This photo says it all
  13. Colin Sweeny (Dylan Baker)
    The creepiest.
  14. Nancy Crozier (Mamie Gummer)
    I copy her "I just don't understand I'm a Midwestern girl" routine every time I need to have something done on my car
  15. Laura Hellinger (Amanda Peet)
    Amanda Peet is a gosh darn delight. She should be in all things
  16. Glenn Childs (Titus Weliever)
    This may be misplaced Lost love
  17. Johnny Elfman (Steven Pasquale)
    I mean he is my least fave of the potential hookups. But at least he got a hook up. THIS IS HOW YOU DO IT FINN
  18. Neil Gross (John Benjamin Hickey)
    Hoodie styling tips. I mean Maroon and a jacket. Tech CEO style is on point
  19. Dean Levine-Wilkins (Taye Diggs)
    They announced Taye Diggs was going to be on the show and everyone was so excited and then he just disappeared.