The classic hair-of-the-dog cocktail is bigger and bolder than ever, with inspired garnishes and premium upgrades.
  1. Jimmy’s Famous American Tavern
    2580803d f438 499a a1a2 a625e52ac315
    This boisterous neighborhood gastropub delivers a one-two punch with its substantial drink. Arriving in a pint glass, the Meal Mary, comes with an amazing spectacle atop it: a skewer jam-packed with Fontina cheese, pepperoncini, a stuffed olive, a shrimp, and a deviled egg. There’s also a thick slice of bacon that stays shatteringly crisp to the last sip, and the requisite celery stalk. Save room for the actual drink: a house-made mix with thick tomato juice and zesty spices.
  2. Lobby Lounge
    Lore has it that in 1934, Fernand Petiot took his original bloody mary recipe to the St. Regis Hotel in New York, where he perfected it. Today, find not one, but six marys at the resort, starting with the Red Snapper made with Ketel One vodka, tomato juice, fresh horseradish, Worcestershire, and lime. Served in a goblet rimmed with celery salt, it’s adorned simply with a leafy celery stalk and a toothpick of pimento olives. The robust and piquant drink is a great balance of savory and tangy.
  3. Taps Fish House & Brewery
    The longtime steakhouse and seafood restaurant claims it has the “world’s greatest bloody mary.” If not it, it’s close. The from-scratch mix—freshly ground horseradish, shallots, A.1. steak sauce, Tabasco, Worcestershire, lemon, and orange juice—is shaken with Skyy vodka for a hearty libation that’s not too thick. Jutting out of the drink is a 9-inch skewer holding a tomolive (pickled tomato), cherry tomato, olive, a chunk of dill pickle, sweet salad pepper, pepperoncini, and a plump shrimp.
  4. 320 Main
    The classic gets a modern update here—in addition to the standard tomato juice, vodka, and Worcestershire, Sriracha replaces the traditional Tabasco, caper juice is added in lieu of a salted rim, and there’s also cumin, which lends a hint of smokiness to the melange of flavors. This drink is for those who may be bored with the classic bloody mary, and ideal for nursing a hangover. No overload of fancy garnishes here, just a celery stick and an olive—the better to save room for, say, brunch.
  5. Ramos House Cafe
    The bloody mary is the star of this historic and charming eatery. Made with Soju (a Korean variation on vodka) and Clamato juice, the cocktail is presented with what looks like an alien bouquet growing out of it. Upon closer inspection, you’ll see it’s a crab claw piercing a Scotch egg—a hard-boiled, deep-fried quail egg wrapped in bacon and glazed with zesty mustard sauce. Pickled green and wax beans also hang over the rim of the glass. The drink is light, not too spicy, and slightly sweet.