One man's trash is another man's pleasure.
  1. Nick Carter
    Look: I'm not going to waste anyone's time, here. Nick Carter is the raison d'être of this group -- fresh-faced, frosted, innocence mixed with its complete opposite. And that lisp, tho.
  2. Kevin Richardson
    Soul patch aside, with a little Stanley Tucci-in-Devil Wears Prada black magic, this dude would look high-fashion af. Also, remember when he played Billy Flynn on Broadway?
  3. Brian Littrell
    He's so sweet that his poor little heart couldn't take it! He's a charming advocate and seems genuinely nice. Also, that cut back to him on that high melisma in the "I Want It That Way" video is major.
  4. Howie Dorough
    So cute but loses a few points due to paucity of vocal pyrotechnics. Sub-ranking of hotness of celebs named Howie: Howie Long (I know) Howie Dorough Howie Day Howie Mandel
  5. A.J. McLean
    I just can't ever forget that he was Skunk on the short-lived TV series Hi, Honey, I'm Home!