My go-to is normally "With Arms Wide Open" but the only rule was "no Creed" soooooo
  1. Summer Nights
  2. I Believe In A Thing Called Love
    And I found out very publicly that I still cannot hit these notes
  3. A Whole New World
    This killed. I mean, it was no amazing woman singing "Last Dance" or the male bartender who is also Macy Gray's voice twin but still.... Also it helped that the lead in was someone doing HOME BY DAUGHTRY 🆘 🆘 🆘 🆘
  4. Superstar
    This was a mistake