1. Noel: Christmas Eve, 1913
    Umm is this a diary entry?? Terrible title, terrible song, and the Muppet:John Denver ratio is way too low
  2. A Baby Just Like You
    Wow is the word "baby" awful. Also John Denver is great and all, but I came here for the Muppets and I want more Muppets!! Janice and Miss Piggy are not backup singers!!
  3. The Peace Carol
    Idk not very memorable
  4. The Christmas Wish
    I wish more more Muppets!!
  5. The Medley
    It's really pretty but it's like 50% talking which might make it a poem????
  6. Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas
    The harmony by Rolf at the end really helps this song out
  7. Deck the Halls
    Very underrated Christmas song, and they all sound like they're just having a great time with each other and that's all I want
  8. When the River Meets the Sea
    It's closest we get to a 70's country song and that's what I want from a country boy like John Denver
  9. Christmas is Coming
    This version is rocking and they sing it in a round and Miss Piggy is HBIC
  10. Little Saint Nick
    Omg Animal with that bass line 👐🏼👐🏼👐🏼👐🏼
  11. Twelve Days Of Christmas
    Beaker singing/beeping the nine ladies dancing is the true meaning of Christmas. Also Miss Piggy is just being the diva we all love. This isn't number one because the album version doesn't have Fozzie Bear like the music video does https://youtu.be/EDBMzGq1vhs
  12. Silent Night
    It starts in German THE MUPPETS ARE BILINGUAL!!!!!! But the history lesson from John Denver in the middle keeps it from the top spot. Hello you just read that from book Wikipedia!!
  13. We Wish You A Merry Christmas
    This song is a BANGER!! Miss Piggy thinking Gonzo is demanding "piggy pudding" kills me 😂😂