Secret Santa Gift Ideas

Got word today that our holiday tradition with the cousins continue. We play the gift swap game. Below are what I've offered in previous years gifts (we used to do straight exchanged before then). $20 limit and my reputation is on the line. Please help me think of something cool. Anyone bringing a gift card has to take a penalty shot.
  1. A treasure chest filled with chocolate gold coins, mini baby Ruth chocolate bars, a DVD of The Goonies and a gift card to Starbucks (because of gentrification)
  2. Magnetic Scrabble board
    My cousin and his girlfriend got it and instagramed their appreciation. I want one of my own if you're trying to figure out what to get me.
  3. Drake Hotline Bling Sweater
    Luckily went to our Drake-enthusiast.
  4. A variety of silicone ice trays.
    Hearts, bears, flamingos and anything Star Wars is what I currently own. Great for making ice cubes and gummies.
    Suggested by   @solitarygigi