I was born in 1986... Keep that in mind and don't judge lol. P.S. This is a JTT-free list.
  1. Paul Walker
    Giphy
    Forever 😭
  2. Leonardo DiCaprio
    Giphy
    Duh.
  3. Mark Wahlberg
    Giphy
    Calvin Klein
  4. Mark-Paul Gosselaar
    Giphy
    What girl didn't love him??????
  5. Devon Sawa
    Giphy
    This was inevitable!! First it was Casper, then Little Giants and then... Just everything ::swoon::
  6. Nick Carter
    Giphy
    This is what happens when you like BSB.. YOU HAVE TO PICK ONE!!
  7. Justin Timberlake
    Giphy
    I betrayed Nick Carter... (In my mind)
  8. Brian Austin Green
    Giphy
    10 years of watching this Vanilla Ice wannabe and he ends up marrying Donna Martin!!
  9. Ryan Phillippe
    Giphy
    I debated this because he seemed short
  10. Zachary Ty Bryan
    Static
    Okay... So this makes me wonder why...